Older Post Newer Post

The Mega Church (may be ranty)

I have friends of almost all faiths. I've got Pagan friends, Christian friends, Catholic friends, Jewish friends, atheist friends, and the "well, maybe there is something, maybe not. Let us ponder this over a beer" friends.

The past decade or so, I've been considered pretty laid back by most of my friends regarding religion. But lately, I've been ranting more and more about the "mega church" and why I think it's not only a bad Christian institution, but why I think it's bad for the community in general.

With apologies to my numerous friends who attend and love these churches, I've seen them personally hurt my business, and nearby businesses. In most cases I don't think it's intentional, but it is happening.

Every mega church decides to put in a coffee shop. Since it's under the umbrella of the church, they don't pay taxes the way my coffee shop has to.
So here is a coffee shop, making profit and not getting taxed. They take business from myself, and from other local coffee shops. Not only that, but I have yet to see a single church coffee shop in our area use a local roaster! How does this support their local economic community?

Now the latest trend, at least where we live, are the church fitness centers. Again, not taxed, so they practically give away memberships. $100 a year for a family of four? Who wouldn't sign up for that???
Meanwhile, other gyms are closing down. So again, mega church using an unfair tax advantage and hurting their local community businesses.


However it's not just the impact on the local economy. I think one of the biggest problems, is that these giant churches, with the coffee house, the day care, the fitness center, the gift shop, and oh yea, a place of worship, no longer require the thing that used to make me admire Christianity so much. Bravery.

What's the braver scenario? A Christian running on a treadmill in their church, next to another member of their congregation, discussing grabbing a coffee on the downstairs level of the church, where maybe they will meet up with other members of the congregation?
OR
A Christian running on a treadmill at a gym. The person next to them can't get their treadmill to work. The Christian helps them out. Every day they run side by side and talk. The Christian is a good example of Christianity. They are kind, they are courteous, they are in general, a good person to be around. The subject of faith comes up. Christian invites non Christian out to discuss things over a coffee, at the local coffee shop. In public. Other people are around. Maybe they'll hear the discussion and ask questions.

The funny thing is I see this brave scenario more with teenagers than I do with adults. All the bible study groups that meet in my shop seem to be teenagers. And when other teenagers try to put them down or snark about their faith, they might get more emotional than an adult would, but they stand their ground, and explain their beliefs.

Maybe I just don't understand the point of the mega church. It seems to create a bubble around the church, so the congregation never has to leave, or go out in the community, or have their faith questioned by someone who might not necessarily believe or understand the things they believe. Once again, it no longer requires bravery, which I think should be a trait in people of all faiths. I would rather see a congregation out and integrated in the community, leading by example.

Leading by example is at least one of the reasons I'm so jazzed up about this subject lately. It's not just their business impacting my business. It's also the people I see that run at least one of these churches. Without going into too much detail, there is local person that set up a fake website (we had the .net of our name, he snagged the .com of our name) and pretended to be my coffee shop. He does espresso bar catering (as I do) and when someone would email, making it very, very clear they thought they were addressing Strange Brew Coffee, he would pretend to be the owner of Strange Brew and book the catering job.

That is one very, very small example of what he does. Every time we catch him at something, we have to pony up to our lawyer to get him to stop. Trying to purchase real estate under our name, impersonating us in emails, purchasing product under our account causing me to get a past due bill... it goes on and on.

What's my point? This man is the director of worship ministries at a local church. In fact, he has "been a transformational leader of God's people in worship". This church isn't a mega church yet, but they want to be. With this type of businessman leading the way.

I know that in 9 times out of 10 these sort of places build up from the best intentions. I just have to wonder if those running the show see or consider the impact it has on their local community.

8 Responses to “The Mega Church (may be ranty)”

  1. You've made some really great points. I'm shocked by the actions of this person. We see this sort of thing happen all of the time in the art world, but someone from a church? Talk about a mixed message.


    http://mandycrandell.blogspot.com/

  2. I don't think this is ranty at all. I think it is one of the most cogent and honest reactions to the megachurch phenomenon I've read, actually.

  3. One other thing, I think you are totally right to point to the way that these other ventures churches do are causing them to withdraw from their communities. The irony, of course, is that they are wanting to use coffee shops and such as a "hook" to draw people into church. But really it just keeps folks from having to deal with those who might make them uncomfortable.

  4. Right! Which is my main complaint. I think whatever your religion, if you want to bring people into it, you need to be out in the community, leading by example. Show people that you are a good person, and impress upon them that the reason you are such a good person is due in a large part to your faith. A non-christian is not going to pop into a coffee shop in a church for their latte. But a member of the church who used to go to their local, may quit making that trip out the door and down the street, and just grab their joe from the church.

  5. Joan, thank you for your insightful observations. I think you have hit several nails right on the head. I am blessed to be a member of a church that believes we are supposed to work alongside our neighbors and we do our best to take our business to the stores, restaurants and yes, coffee shops around us. It might warm your heart to know that when we host big conferences, a friend of mine insists on serving locally roasted coffee. It is a small decision, but a relatively easy one to make and has profound implications for our relationships with people and organizations around our city. Thanks for confirming for me that I am part of an amazing group of people.

  6. I live in Austin, the land of "Support Local Business", and I couldn't agree with you more. I don't for one second think that churches are meant to act like Wal-Mart.

    I get to Indianapolis about once a year-- next time I'm in town, I am definitely going to drop by your coffee shop.

  7. You have a lot more Christian insight, than some Christians.

  8. So, I've known you since I was fifteen years old... and you've known me to be an okay Christian since then. I actually have a problem with mega churches that is more on a biblical level than your rant. Jesus didn't like people selling wares at a place of worship. He actually flipped out once and started whipping people who were doing this. It makes me actually uncomfortable to see churches with coffee shops inside, like I'm scared Jesus is gonna come down and flip out on me for looking at it... probably isn't going to happen, but why don't church people (not Christians, I don't consider the two groups synonymous) see that as something Jesus expressly forbid?

© 2006-2010 by Joan of Dark® unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved.. Powered by Blogger.
© 2010 joanofdark.com joanofdark.com .